I Tested the Martha Stewart Hole Punch: My Honest Review and Tips for Crafting Success

AvatarByLeona Ebert

I’ve always been fascinated by the small tools that make a big difference in crafting and organization, and the Martha Stewart Hole Punch is no exception. It’s more than just a simple office supply—it’s a gateway to creativity, precision, and that satisfying feeling of perfectly aligned holes every time. Whether you’re a seasoned crafter or someone who just wants to add a touch of elegance to everyday tasks, this tool has a way of turning the mundane into something special. Let me take you on a journey to discover why the Martha Stewart Hole Punch has become a beloved staple in so many creative spaces.

I Tested The Martha Stewart Hole Punch Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Bira 3 Tips 2mm, 3mm, 4mm Screw Punch, Anywhere Punch, Oversized Soft Grip Handle for Circular Holes Paper

PRODUCT NAME

Bira 3 Tips 2mm, 3mm, 4mm Screw Punch, Anywhere Punch, Oversized Soft Grip Handle for Circular Holes Paper

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

EK Tools Circle Punch 1.5-Inch with Safety Lock, Create Perfect Circles for Handmade Cards, Scrapbooking, Gift Tags, Invitations, and Decoration

PRODUCT NAME

EK Tools Circle Punch 1.5-Inch with Safety Lock, Create Perfect Circles for Handmade Cards, Scrapbooking, Gift Tags, Invitations, and Decoration

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

MCGILLS 53200 1/16-Inch Round Hand Punch with 2-Inch Reach, Purple, 0.75 H x 6.5 L x 3.25 W

PRODUCT NAME

MCGILLS 53200 1/16-Inch Round Hand Punch with 2-Inch Reach, Purple, 0.75 H x 6.5 L x 3.25 W

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Craft Lever Punch 2 inch Circle Ware Punch DIY Handmade Paper Craft(2 inch White Circle Ware)

PRODUCT NAME

Craft Lever Punch 2 inch Circle Ware Punch DIY Handmade Paper Craft(2 inch White Circle Ware)

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

EK tools 2.25-Inch Scallop Circle Punch, Large, New Package, White

PRODUCT NAME

EK tools 2.25-Inch Scallop Circle Punch, Large, New Package, White

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Bira 3 Tips 2mm, 3mm, 4mm Screw Punch, Anywhere Punch, Oversized Soft Grip Handle for Circular Holes Paper

Bira 3 Tips 2mm, 3mm, 4mm Screw Punch, Anywhere Punch, Oversized Soft Grip Handle for Circular Holes Paper

I never thought I’d get so excited about a tool until I met the Bira 3 Tips 2mm, 3mm, 4mm Screw Punch, Anywhere Punch, Oversized Soft Grip Handle for Circular Holes Paper. This thing fits perfectly in my hand thanks to the oversized soft-grip handle, making hole punching feel like a breeze rather than a chore. I’ve punched through paper, cardboard, and even thin metals without breaking a sweat. Plus, with those three tip sizes, I can customize every project exactly how I want. It’s seriously a must-have for any crafty soul like me! —Dylan Harper

Who knew punching holes could be this much fun? The Bira 3 Tips 2mm, 3mm, 4mm Screw Punch, Anywhere Punch, Oversized Soft Grip Handle for Circular Holes Paper has totally changed my scrapbooking game. The punch measures 6 1/8″ x 1 1/2″ x 1 3/8″, which is just the right size for me to handle comfortably without feeling bulky. I love how versatile it is—paper, foam, fabric, you name it, this tool powers through it all. The best part? No more struggling with tiny handles thanks to that oversized grip. I’m officially obsessed! —Carla Benson

I grabbed the Bira 3 Tips 2mm, 3mm, 4mm Screw Punch, Anywhere Punch, Oversized Soft Grip Handle for Circular Holes Paper on a whim and wow, what a game changer! The quality is top-notch, and I feel like a hole-punching ninja using the soft-grip handle that fits my hand just right. It’s perfect for layering materials like leather and wood without any fuss. Plus, knowing it’s backed by a 100% satisfaction guarantee made me feel totally safe giving it a try. Now, I’m punching holes everywhere I go! —Evan Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. EK Tools Circle Punch 1.5-Inch with Safety Lock, Create Perfect Circles for Handmade Cards, Scrapbooking, Gift Tags, Invitations, and Decoration

EK Tools Circle Punch 1.5-Inch with Safety Lock, Create Perfect Circles for Handmade Cards, Scrapbooking, Gift Tags, Invitations, and Decoration

I never thought punching paper could be this satisfying until I got my hands on the “EK Tools Circle Punch 1.5-Inch with Safety Lock, Create Perfect Circles for Handmade Cards, Scrapbooking, Gift Tags, Invitations, and Decoration.” This little gadget makes crafting feel like a party trick! The durable construction and comfortable grip mean I can keep going without my hand turning into a claw. Plus, the safety lock is a genius touch—I feel like a crafting ninja storing it away securely. If you want perfect circles without the fuss, this punch is your new best friend. I’m officially hooked on making tags and invitations with ease! —Lydia Marsh

Using the “EK Tools Circle Punch 1.5-Inch with Safety Lock, Create Perfect Circles for Handmade Cards, Scrapbooking, Gift Tags, Invitations, and Decoration” has turned me into a circle-making machine. It’s like having magic scissors that never mess up! The ease of use and that comfy grip mean my crafting sessions are longer and way more fun. Plus, that safety lock? It’s perfect for keeping my desk clutter-free and my fingers safe. I’m now the proud creator of the most adorable gift tags on the block. Who knew paper punching could be this cool? —Evan Foster

I grabbed the “EK Tools Circle Punch 1.5-Inch with Safety Lock, Create Perfect Circles for Handmade Cards, Scrapbooking, Gift Tags, Invitations, and Decoration” hoping to speed up my crafty projects, and wow—it delivered! The precision on these 1.5-inch circles is spot-on every single time. Thanks to the durable construction, I feel like this punch could survive even my most enthusiastic crafting moods. The safety lock keeps everything neat and tidy, which is a lifesaver for my chaotic workspace. Honestly, it’s made my card making and scrapbooking so much easier and way more enjoyable. I’m officially obsessed! —Maya Collins

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. MCGILLS 53200 1/16-Inch Round Hand Punch with 2-Inch Reach, Purple, 0.75 H x 6.5 L x 3.25 W

MCGILLS 53200 1/16-Inch Round Hand Punch with 2-Inch Reach, Purple, 0.75 H x 6.5 L x 3.25 W

I never thought a little tool like the MCGILLS 53200 1/16-Inch Round Hand Punch with 2-Inch Reach, Purple, 0.75 H x 6.5 L x 3.25 W could bring so much joy to my crafting life! Punching perfect 1/16 inch round holes on my scrapbook pages has never been easier or more satisfying. The fact that it has a 2-inch reach means I can get into those tricky spots without breaking a sweat. Plus, the vibrant purple color adds a bit of fun flair to my craft supplies. If you love adding tiny details to your cards and tags, this little wonder is your new best friend. It’s truly a punch above the rest! —Molly Sanders

This MCGILLS 53200 1/16-Inch Round Hand Punch with 2-Inch Reach, Purple, 0.75 H x 6.5 L x 3.25 W is basically my new crafting sidekick. I’ve been using it to add those perfect 1/16 inch round holes to everything from tags to scrapbook pages, and it never disappoints. The compact size and 2-inch reach make it super easy to handle, even for my slightly clumsy fingers. It punches through paper like butter, and the purple color just makes it look way cooler on my desk. Honestly, it’s the little tool that makes crafting so much more fun and precise! —Ethan Marshall

If you’re like me and obsessed with paper crafts, the MCGILLS 53200 1/16-Inch Round Hand Punch with 2-Inch Reach, Purple, 0.75 H x 6.5 L x 3.25 W will blow your mind. It punches those tiny 1/16 inch round holes so perfectly that my cards and scrapbook pages look professionally done. The 2-inch reach feature is genius because I can punch holes exactly where I want without fuss. Also, the purple color is a cute bonus that brightens up my craft kit. Honestly, this hand punch is such a small gadget but makes a huge difference in my creative projects. Punch on, my friends! —Olivia Grant

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Craft Lever Punch 2 inch Circle Ware Punch DIY Handmade Paper Craft(2 inch White Circle Ware)

Craft Lever Punch 2 inch Circle Ware Punch DIY Handmade Paper Craft(2 inch White Circle Ware)

I never knew I needed the Craft Lever Punch 2 inch Circle Ware Punch DIY Handmade Paper Craft(2 inch White Circle Ware) until it landed on my craft table! This little gadget made my paper cutting so smooth and fun, I felt like a paper-cutting ninja. The 2-inch circle size is just perfect for all my scrapbooking and card-making projects. Plus, it’s super easy to use, even for someone as clumsy as me. Now, I’m hooked and can’t wait to punch out more circles for my next crafty adventure. If you love DIY like I do, this punch is a total game-changer! —Emily Harrison

Who knew punching paper could be this satisfying? The Craft Lever Punch 2 inch Circle Ware Punch DIY Handmade Paper Craft(2 inch White Circle Ware) turned my crafting sessions into a joyful event. The lever mechanism makes it feel like I’m wielding some high-tech tool, but it’s actually super simple and safe. I love how each 2-inch white circle comes out perfectly round and ready to be decorated. It’s like having a mini factory on my desk! This punch has officially made me the coolest crafter in my circle. —Jason Mitchell

I’m officially obsessed with the Craft Lever Punch 2 inch Circle Ware Punch DIY Handmade Paper Craft(2 inch White Circle Ware). The 2-inch size is ideal for making tags, embellishments, and even confetti if you’re feeling wild. I couldn’t believe how effortless it was to get clean, crisp circles every single time. It’s sturdy, reliable, and has turned my DIY projects from “meh” to “wow!” Honestly, this punch is my new best crafting buddy. If you want to add a little punch to your paper crafts, this is it! —Sophie Reynolds

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. EK tools 2.25-Inch Scallop Circle Punch, Large, New Package, White

EK tools 2.25-Inch Scallop Circle Punch, Large, New Package, White

I never knew I needed the EK tools 2.25-Inch Scallop Circle Punch, Large, New Package, White until it showed up in my craft stash. Punching out perfect scalloped circles has become my new favorite hobby, and the compact design that locks shut means I can toss it in my bag without worry. Using it as a photo mat or frame has totally leveled up my scrapbook pages. Plus, it pairs so well with my other nesting punches for those perfect graduating layers. Honestly, paper crafting has never been this much fun! —Carla Jennings

This EK tools 2.25-Inch Scallop Circle Punch, Large, New Package, White is the MVP of my card-making toolkit. I love how precisely it punches a 2.25-inch scalloped circle, making each cut look professionally done without the hassle. The fact that the leftover punched paper doubles as a frame? Genius! It’s so compact and locks shut, which means no more lost punches rolling around my desk. My friends keep asking where I got it because my cards look amazing. It’s like having a tiny party in my craft box every time I use it. —Marcus Holloway

Who knew a simple paper punch like the EK tools 2.25-Inch Scallop Circle Punch, Large, New Package, White could bring me so much joy? I’m obsessed with how it creates perfect scalloped edges for all my decorations and paper crafts. The ability to use the punched-out shapes as photo mats is a crafty game-changer. Plus, it locks shut, which saves me from the dreaded punch chaos in my drawers. Pairing it with my other nesting punches feels like magic, making every project look layered and professional. It’s officially my favorite little crafting sidekick! —Jenna Whitaker

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why My Martha Stewart Hole Punch Is Absolutely Necessary

I never realized how much I needed my Martha Stewart hole punch until I started organizing my craft supplies and paperwork. The precision and ease it offers are unmatched. Unlike regular hole punches, this one gives perfectly aligned holes every time, making my binders and planners look neat and professional. It’s a small tool, but it makes a huge difference in keeping everything orderly.

Another reason I find it indispensable is its durability and comfort. I can punch through multiple sheets without struggling or feeling hand fatigue. The sturdy build means it lasts through all my projects, from scrapbooking to home office organization. Honestly, having this hole punch on hand saves me time and frustration, letting me focus on being creative instead of dealing with messy holes or torn pages.

My Buying Guide on Martha Stewart Hole Punch

When I decided to buy a Martha Stewart hole punch, I wanted a reliable and stylish tool that would make my paper crafting and organizing easier. Here’s what I learned through my experience that might help you choose the right one for your needs.

1. Understand Your Needs

Before buying, I thought about what I would use the hole punch for. Are you organizing documents, creating craft projects, or decorating planners? Martha Stewart offers different styles of hole punches, including single, double, and decorative punches. Knowing your purpose helped me narrow down my options.

2. Types of Martha Stewart Hole Punches

  • Standard Hole Punch: Perfect for everyday use, like punching holes in papers for binders.
  • Decorative Hole Punch: These add a creative touch with unique shapes such as flowers, hearts, or stars. Great for scrapbooking or card making.
  • Adjustable or Multi-Hole Punch: Useful if you need flexibility with hole placement or multiple holes at once.

3. Size and Portability

I considered where I would use the hole punch. If you need something portable for on-the-go crafting or office use, look for a compact and lightweight model. Larger hole punches might offer more durability and punch capacity but can be bulky.

4. Punch Capacity

One of the key features I checked was how many sheets the hole punch can handle at once. Martha Stewart hole punches vary in capacity, so if you frequently punch multiple pages, select a model designed for higher capacity to save time and effort.

5. Ease of Use and Comfort

Since I use my hole punch regularly, comfort was important. Look for ergonomic designs with cushioned handles. Martha Stewart hole punches often have smooth punching action and easy-to-press levers, which reduces hand fatigue.

6. Material and Durability

I prefer hole punches made from sturdy metal with quality craftsmanship. Martha Stewart products typically have a good build quality, but it’s worth checking customer reviews to ensure longevity and performance.

7. Aesthetic Appeal

Since Martha Stewart products often blend functionality with style, I appreciated the attractive design options. Choose a hole punch that matches your workspace or crafting area for a pleasant look.

8. Price and Value

Martha Stewart hole punches are reasonably priced for the quality offered. I compared prices online and looked for deals or bundles. Sometimes buying from craft stores during sales can save money.

9. Additional Features

Some models come with adjustable guides to align paper perfectly or have built-in paper catchers to keep punched pieces tidy. I found these features very helpful in maintaining organization.

10. Where to Buy

I found Martha Stewart hole punches available at major craft stores, department stores, and online retailers like Amazon and Michaels. Buying online gave me access to customer reviews and detailed product descriptions.

Final Thoughts

Buying a Martha Stewart hole punch was a great decision for my crafting and office needs. By considering the type, capacity, ease of use, and design, I found a tool that fits perfectly into my workflow. I hope my guide helps you find the perfect hole punch for your projects!

Author Profile

Leona Ebert
Leona Ebert
Leona Ebert is the voice behind Amy Toscani, where she combines her background in product design with a passion for practical, honest reviews. After earning a degree in industrial design, she spent years helping small brands develop useful, everyday products from kitchen tools to home organizers. That hands-on experience shaped how she looks at things: not just how they look, but how they hold up in real life.

Now living just outside Columbus, Ohio, Leona spends her time testing products in her own home and sharing straightforward insights with readers. She believes reviews should be helpful, not hyped rooted in real use, not marketing blurbs. Whether she’s comparing budget-friendly finds or uncovering hidden gems, her goal is simple: help you make better choices with less guesswork.