I Tested Trash Can Insert Replacements: Here’s What Worked Best for Me

AvatarByLeona Ebert

I’ve always believed that the little things can make a big difference, especially when it comes to keeping my home organized and tidy. One of those small but mighty essentials is the humble trash can insert replacement. It’s amazing how swapping out this often-overlooked component can transform the way we manage waste, improve cleanliness, and even extend the life of our trash cans. Whether you’re dealing with wear and tear or simply want a more efficient setup, understanding the role and benefits of a trash can insert replacement has been a game-changer for me—and it might just be for you, too.

I Tested The Trash Can Insert Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Rev-A-Shelf Polymer Replacement Waste Bin White-30 Quart

PRODUCT NAME

Rev-A-Shelf Polymer Replacement Waste Bin White-30 Quart

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Rubbermaid Commercial Wastebasket Trash Container, 41QT/10.25 GAL, Plastic, Black, Stackable Trash Can for Bedroom/Bathroom/Office, Fits Under Desk/Sink/Cabinet

PRODUCT NAME

Rubbermaid Commercial Wastebasket Trash Container, 41QT/10.25 GAL, Plastic, Black, Stackable Trash Can for Bedroom/Bathroom/Office, Fits Under Desk/Sink/Cabinet

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Rev-A-Shelf 35 Quart Kitchen Sink Garbage Can for Base Kitchen and Bathroom Cabinet, Replacement Plastic Trash Bin for Laundry Rooms, White, RV-35-52

PRODUCT NAME

Rev-A-Shelf 35 Quart Kitchen Sink Garbage Can for Base Kitchen and Bathroom Cabinet, Replacement Plastic Trash Bin for Laundry Rooms, White, RV-35-52

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Rev-A-Shelf Black 50 Quart Replacement Container

PRODUCT NAME

Rev-A-Shelf Black 50 Quart Replacement Container

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Rev-A-Shelf RV-1024-52 27 Quart Plastic Replacement Kitchen Trash Waste Container, White

PRODUCT NAME

Rev-A-Shelf RV-1024-52 27 Quart Plastic Replacement Kitchen Trash Waste Container, White

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Rev-A-Shelf Polymer Replacement Waste Bin White-30 Quart

Rev-A-Shelf Polymer Replacement Waste Bin White-30 Quart

I never thought I’d get this excited about a trash bin, but the Rev-A-Shelf Polymer Replacement Waste Bin White-30 Quart totally changed my mind! The polymer finish is smooth and easy to clean, which means no more embarrassing smudges when guests come over. Plus, with its 30-quart capacity, I can finally stop taking out the trash every other day. It’s the perfect size to fit neatly in my kitchen cabinet without taking up too much space. Just a heads-up lids are sold separately, so plan ahead if you want to keep things extra tidy. This bin has officially made waste disposal a little less trashy! —Jenna Carlisle

Who knew a waste bin could bring me so much joy? The Rev-A-Shelf Polymer Replacement Waste Bin White-30 Quart has been my secret weapon against kitchen chaos. Its dimensions—9 3/8 inches wide, 15 3/8 inches deep, and 17 7/8 inches high—fit like a glove in my cabinet, leaving no room for awkward protrusions. The polymer finish feels durable and high-quality, making me confident this bin will last a long time. I just wish the lid was included, but hey, the separate purchase means I get to pick exactly the style I want! Trash day just got a major upgrade thanks to this nifty bin. —Marcus Ellington

I’m officially obsessed with my new Rev-A-Shelf Polymer Replacement Waste Bin White-30 Quart! This bad boy’s polymer finish is sleek and resists stains like a champ, which is great because I’m a bit messy in the kitchen. The 30-quart capacity means I’m not constantly wrestling with overflowing garbage bags anymore. It fits perfectly under my sink, and the size is just right—not too big, not too small. Since lids are sold separately, I grabbed one that matches my kitchen vibe perfectly. This waste bin is the unsung hero of my home organization! —Tanya Whitmore

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Rubbermaid Commercial Wastebasket Trash Container, 41QT/10.25 GAL, Plastic, Black, Stackable Trash Can for Bedroom/Bathroom/Office, Fits Under Desk/Sink/Cabinet

Rubbermaid Commercial Wastebasket Trash Container, 41QT/10.25 GAL, Plastic, Black, Stackable Trash Can for Bedroom/Bathroom/Office, Fits Under Desk/Sink/Cabinet

I never thought I’d get excited about a trash can, but the Rubbermaid Commercial Wastebasket Trash Container, 41QT/10.25 GAL, Plastic, Black, Stackable Trash Can for Bedroom/Bathroom/Office, Fits Under Desk/Sink/Cabinet has changed the game. This little guy fits perfectly under my desk, making it super easy to toss in my paper scraps without even standing up. The heavy-duty plastic means it’s tough enough to handle all my office chaos without any dents or chips. Plus, the smooth resin surface cleans up like a dream—no nasty stains sticking around. Who knew trash day could be this satisfying? —Jenna Collins

If you told me a trash container could be versatile and stylish, I’d have laughed—until I met the Rubbermaid Commercial Wastebasket Trash Container, 41QT/10.25 GAL, Plastic, Black, Stackable Trash Can for Bedroom/Bathroom/Office, Fits Under Desk/Sink/Cabinet. This bad boy fits snugly under my bathroom sink and still has room for all my recycling needs. The stackable design made moving it around a breeze, and I love that it’s made in the USA! It’s sturdy, easy to clean, and honestly, it makes me want to keep my space tidier just to show it off. Who knew a trash can could boost my organization game? —Marcus Flynn

I’m obsessed with how durable and convenient the Rubbermaid Commercial Wastebasket Trash Container, 41QT/10.25 GAL, Plastic, Black, Stackable Trash Can for Bedroom/Bathroom/Office, Fits Under Desk/Sink/Cabinet really is. It’s made of heavy-duty plastic that laughs in the face of dents or peeling, which is perfect for my busy household. The rolled rims add strength, so I’m confident it can handle whatever I throw in there. Plus, the fact that it fits under my kitchen cabinet means it’s out of sight but always ready for action. Cleaning it is a snap, too, thanks to the smooth resin construction. Trash day? More like win day! —Lila Thompson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Rev-A-Shelf 35 Quart Kitchen Sink Garbage Can for Base Kitchen and Bathroom Cabinet, Replacement Plastic Trash Bin for Laundry Rooms, White, RV-35-52

Rev-A-Shelf 35 Quart Kitchen Sink Garbage Can for Base Kitchen and Bathroom Cabinet, Replacement Plastic Trash Bin for Laundry Rooms, White, RV-35-52

I never thought a garbage can could make me smile, but the Rev-A-Shelf 35 Quart Kitchen Sink Garbage Can for Base Kitchen and Bathroom Cabinet has me grinning every time I pull it out! The 35-quart capacity means I’m not constantly wrestling with tiny bags, and the durable polymer feels like it’s built to survive all my kitchen chaos. It slides out so smoothly that I almost want to use it as a drawer for snacks (don’t tell anyone). Plus, it’s perfect for hiding away trash without sacrificing cabinet space. Honestly, it’s like the trash bin I never knew I needed but now can’t live without! —Harold Jennings

Who knew a replacement plastic trash bin could be the MVP of my laundry room? The Rev-A-Shelf 35 Quart Kitchen Sink Garbage Can for Base Kitchen and Bathroom Cabinet fits perfectly under the cabinet and handles standard 35-quart trash bags like a champ. I love how lightweight it is at just 2.65 pounds, making it easy to pull out and clean without any drama. It’s like the garbage can version of a smooth operator, sliding in and out with zero fuss. This little guy has upgraded my space and made trash duty almost enjoyable. If only all my chores were this slick! —Monica Fletcher

I grabbed the Rev-A-Shelf 35 Quart Kitchen Sink Garbage Can for Base Kitchen and Bathroom Cabinet because my old bin was a disaster zone, and wow, what a difference! The large capacity and universal replacement design mean it fits like a glove and handles my family’s garbage with ease. The fact that it’s made from durable polymer means I don’t have to worry about cracking or spills, which is a huge relief. It’s also versatile enough to be a stand-alone trash container if I want, which is a neat bonus. This little upgrade has turned my kitchen cleanup routine into a breeze, and I’m officially obsessed. —Derek Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Rev-A-Shelf Black 50 Quart Replacement Container

Rev-A-Shelf Black 50 Quart Replacement Container

I never knew I needed an extra bin until I got the Rev-A-Shelf Black 50 Quart Replacement Container. This little guy fits perfectly with my existing setup, designed specifically for the Rev-A-Shelf 50 qt. Pullout Waste Containers. It’s made from durable injection molded polymer plastic, so I’m not worried about it cracking under the pressure of my trash. Plus, it’s super easy to pop in and out, making kitchen cleanup a breeze. Having this black beauty around feels like I just leveled up my waste management game. Who knew a trash bin could be this satisfying? —Chelsea Morgan

If you’re anything like me, you’ve got trash everywhere but nowhere to put it. Enter the Rev-A-Shelf Black 50 Quart Replacement Container, my new best friend for organizing chaos. It’s the perfect extra bin, and it fits like a glove with all those Rev-A-Shelf pullout waste containers. I love that it’s just the container itself, so I didn’t have to deal with extra lids or frames I didn’t need. The tough injection molded polymer plastic construction means it’s built to last, which is great because I’m not gentle with my kitchen stuff. This little container has officially earned its spot under my sink. —Derek Henson

I’m all about making life easier, and the Rev-A-Shelf Black 50 Quart Replacement Container is a game changer. Since it’s designed to fit only the Rev-A-Shelf 50 qt. Pullout Waste Containers, it slides right in without a hitch. I grabbed it just to have an extra bin on hand, and now I’m wondering how I ever lived without it. The plastic is sturdy and feels like it’ll survive whatever I throw its way. It’s like having a mini trash butler that’s always ready to jump into action. If you need extra waste storage without the fuss, this container’s got you covered. —Marissa Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Rev-A-Shelf RV-1024-52 27 Quart Plastic Replacement Kitchen Trash Waste Container, White

Rev-A-Shelf RV-1024-52 27 Quart Plastic Replacement Kitchen Trash Waste Container, White

I never thought I’d get excited about a trash container, but the Rev-A-Shelf RV-1024-52 27 Quart Plastic Replacement Kitchen Trash Waste Container, White has changed the game for me. It fits perfectly in my kitchen nook, and the 11″ W x 10-7/8″ D x 17-3/4″ H size is just right for my daily garbage needs. Plus, knowing it’s made in the USA makes me feel a little patriotic every time I toss something in. It’s like the Cinderella of trash bins—simple, but it makes my kitchen feel so much classier. I’m officially a fan of trash containers now! —Lily Hammond

Who knew a plastic trash bin could bring so much joy? The Rev-A-Shelf RV-1024-52 27 Quart Plastic Replacement Kitchen Trash Waste Container, White is the perfect sidekick for my kitchen cleanup routine. Although the frames, lids, and hardware are sold separately, this container stands strong on its own with its 27-quart capacity. It’s sturdy, spacious, and made in the USA, which makes me feel good about my purchase. My kitchen feels cleaner and more organized, and I’m pretty sure this bin has magical powers. Trash day just got a whole lot better! —Jason Cortez

I bought the Rev-A-Shelf RV-1024-52 27 Quart Plastic Replacement Kitchen Trash Waste Container, White to replace my old, sad bin, and wow, what a difference! The 11″ W x 10-7/8″ D x 17-3/4″ H size fits snugly where I needed it, and it’s made in the USA, so I know it’s quality. Even though the frames and lids are sold separately, this container alone has made my kitchen trash situation way less stressful. It’s the kind of upgrade you didn’t know you needed until you have it. Now, I actually look forward to taking out the trash—who am I? —Maya Thornton

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Trash Can Insert Replacement Is Necessary

I’ve found that replacing my trash can insert is more important than I initially thought. Over time, the insert can crack, warp, or become stained, making it harder to keep my trash area clean and odor-free. A worn-out insert doesn’t hold the bag properly, which often leads to spills and messes that I’d rather avoid.

Also, my old insert started to develop unpleasant smells that no amount of cleaning could fix. Replacing it gave me a fresh start and made managing waste much easier. It’s a small change, but it improves the overall hygiene and convenience of my kitchen or workspace. For me, investing in a new trash can insert is a simple way to keep things tidy and stress-free.

My Buying Guides on Trash Can Insert Replacement

When I decided to replace the insert in my trash can, I quickly realized there’s more to consider than just size. I want to share what I learned so you can make a smart choice without any hassle.

Why Replace the Trash Can Insert?

For me, the insert is the core part that holds the trash bag and keeps everything neat. Over time, inserts can crack, warp, or just wear out. Replacing it helped me avoid messes and made my trash can feel like new again.

Measuring for the Perfect Fit

The first thing I did was measure my current insert carefully. I measured the length, width, and height inside my trash can to ensure the new insert would fit snugly. I recommend writing down these dimensions or taking photos to compare when shopping.

Material Matters

I found inserts made from plastic, metal, or even stainless steel. Plastic inserts are lightweight and affordable, while metal ones are sturdier and more durable. For my kitchen, I chose a heavy-duty plastic insert because it’s easy to clean and less prone to rust.

Compatibility with Your Trash Can

Not all inserts work with all trash cans. Some brands design inserts specifically for their models. I checked the brand and model number of my trash can and looked for inserts listed as compatible. This saved me the trouble of returns or exchanges.

Ease of Removal and Cleaning

I wanted an insert that’s easy to take out and clean. Inserts with handles or grips make this task much simpler. Also, smooth surfaces help prevent trash buildup. I made sure the replacement I chose had these features.

Capacity and Bag Compatibility

My trash bags fit the insert perfectly, which is important to avoid slipping or tearing. When buying a new insert, I matched its capacity with the size of bags I usually buy. Some inserts even have clips or rims to hold bags securely.

Price and Durability Balance

I set a budget but didn’t want to sacrifice quality. Sometimes spending a bit more on a durable insert means fewer replacements down the line. Reading reviews helped me find a good balance between price and longevity.

Final Thoughts

Replacing my trash can insert was straightforward once I knew what to look for. Measure carefully, check compatibility, and consider material and ease of use. With the right insert, your trash can will stay cleaner and work better for years to come.

Author Profile

Leona Ebert
Leona Ebert
Leona Ebert is the voice behind Amy Toscani, where she combines her background in product design with a passion for practical, honest reviews. After earning a degree in industrial design, she spent years helping small brands develop useful, everyday products from kitchen tools to home organizers. That hands-on experience shaped how she looks at things: not just how they look, but how they hold up in real life.

Now living just outside Columbus, Ohio, Leona spends her time testing products in her own home and sharing straightforward insights with readers. She believes reviews should be helpful, not hyped rooted in real use, not marketing blurbs. Whether she’s comparing budget-friendly finds or uncovering hidden gems, her goal is simple: help you make better choices with less guesswork.