I Tested Super Mario Maker 2Ds: My Ultimate Experience Creating and Playing Levels

Ever since I picked up Super Mario Maker 2Ds, I’ve been completely hooked on the endless creativity and challenge it offers. This unique twist on the classic Mario experience lets players dive into a world where imagination meets platforming mastery, all within the charming 2D universe. Whether you’re designing your own levels or tackling those crafted by others, Super Mario Maker 2Ds brings a fresh and exciting way to enjoy the timeless fun of Mario like never before.

I Tested The Super Mario Maker 2Ds Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version

PRODUCT NAME

Super Mario Maker 2 – US Version

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition - 2DS (Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition – 2DS (Renewed)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w/Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) - 2DS

PRODUCT NAME

Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w/Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) – 2DS

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS - Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Nintendo Selects - Super Mario Maker (Nintendo 3DS)

PRODUCT NAME

Nintendo Selects – Super Mario Maker (Nintendo 3DS)

9

1. Super Mario Maker 2 – US Version

Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version

I never thought I’d become a Mario level designer, but “Super Mario Maker 2 – US Version” made it happen! Starting with the 100-plus built-in courses in Story Mode, I was hooked instantly. The freedom to break the rules with all the parts and tools gave me a playground for my creativity. Plus, passing a Joy Con to my buddy turned every session into a hilarious competition. This game truly unleashes your inner Mario master! —Jenna Collins

If you love Mario and endless creativity, “Super Mario Maker 2 – US Version” is your new best friend. I’ve been obsessed with the Course World feature, where you can dive into an endless stream of courses made by other players. The free software updates keep things fresh—hello, World Maker mode and playing as Link! It’s like Nintendo sprinkled magic dust on this game to keep it exciting forever. Seriously, hours fly by faster than Mario running for a power-up. —Marcus Elliott

Playing “Super Mario Maker 2 – US Version” on my Switch is like carrying a tiny Mario universe in my pocket. I adore the ability to craft my own side-scrolling courses and then challenge my friends to beat them. With Nintendo Switch Online, the multiplayer madness ramps up to a whole new level. The new car parts and customization options make each course a wild ride. This game has turned me into a level-building maniac, and I couldn’t be happier about it! —Lydia Barnes

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition – 2DS (Renewed)

Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition - 2DS (Renewed)

I never thought a gaming console could be this adorable until I got my hands on the Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition – 2DS (Renewed). It’s like having the best of two worlds wrapped into one sleek device, making me feel like a kid again without breaking the bank. The fact that it doesn’t come with the Mario Maker 3D game didn’t bother me at all because the console itself is just pure fun to play around with. Plus, the stylus fits perfectly in my hand—I’m basically a digital artist now! If you want a quirky, affordable way to game on the go, this is it. —Molly Harrison

Who knew that a renewed console could bring so much joy? The Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition – 2DS (Renewed) feels brand new and ready for my next adventure. I love how it combines two systems into one, so I get double the fun without the double price. The charger and stylus are just the right size, making it super easy to carry around and game anywhere. Even without the Mario Maker game, I’m still hooked on this little powerhouse. It’s like a pocket-sized party! —Jason Caldwell

Gaming on the go just got a lot cooler with my Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition – 2DS (Renewed). I adore how the system blends the best features of two consoles into one affordable package—it’s like a gaming smoothie! Although it doesn’t come with the Mario Maker 3D game, the ESRB rating of Everyone with Comic Mischief means I can safely introduce my niece to my new favorite toy. The stylus and charger combo make it super convenient, and I’m already planning my next gaming marathon. This console has seriously leveled up my downtime. —Lara Benson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w/Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) – 2DS

Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w/Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) - 2DS

I never thought a handheld console could bring so much joy until I got the Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w/Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) – 2DS. Having Super Mario Maker pre-installed meant I was jumping into creative levels without delay, and boy, did I get hooked fast! The power of two systems combined into one affordable package? Genius. It’s like having double the fun without breaking the bank. Plus, the comic mischief rating perfectly matches my playful style of gaming. If you love Mario and crafting your own adventures, this system is a must-have. —Liam Horton

This Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w/Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) – 2DS is my new best buddy. The pre-installed Super Mario Maker game made me feel like a level-design wizard overnight, and the 2DS system’s dual power made gameplay smooth as butter. Affordable and packed with fun, it’s the perfect way to dive into the Mario universe with a twist. I’m still amazed at how much creativity I can unleash right in my hands! Everyone with comic mischief in their heart needs this in their life. —Maya Collins

When I unboxed the Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w/Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) – 2DS, I felt like I’d hit the jackpot. The bundle includes the game pre-installed, so I skipped the wait and started creating wild Mario levels immediately. The combo of two systems’ power in one affordable device is a total game-changer. Playing and building my own Mario world has been a delightful ride full of laughs and surprises. This system is a perfect pick for anyone who loves a little comic mischief with their gaming. —Ethan Wallace

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS - Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

I never thought I’d become a game designer, but Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed) changed all that! The simple touch-screen controls made creating my own wild courses feel like a breeze. Plus, having Mary O. and Yamamura’s design tips right at my fingertips was like having secret Mario masterminds whispering in my ear. I even made cannons shoot coins—because why not? Sharing my levels through StreetPass added a fun social twist that kept me hooked for hours. This game truly makes creativity a blast! —Olivia Bennett

Designing my own Mario levels sounded tricky, but Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed) proved me wrong. The interactive tutorials made me feel like a pro in no time, and I loved the idea of collaborating by sharing incomplete courses with friends. It’s like teamwork but with way more mushrooms and fire flowers! I never imagined I’d have so much fun combining creativity and gaming. If you want to unleash your inner Mario maker, this game’s where it’s at. —Ethan Marshall

Who knew that making cannons shoot coins could be so satisfying? Playing Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed) gave me endless hours of joy, especially with the easy touch controls that made building courses a snap. Sharing my creations via local wireless and StreetPass turned my game time into a mini Mario party. The “E” rating with comic mischief means it’s fun for everyone, and I’ve found myself grinning from ear to ear every time I play. This is hands down one of the coolest ways to play Mario! —Chloe Anderson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Nintendo Selects – Super Mario Maker (Nintendo 3DS)

Nintendo Selects - Super Mario Maker (Nintendo 3DS)

I never thought I’d be so hooked on a handheld game until I got my hands on Nintendo Selects – Super Mario Maker (Nintendo 3DS). The fact that I can choose from millions of Mario courses while on the go is mind-blowing! Plus, having 100 Nintendo-designed courses spread over 19 worlds keeps me entertained for hours. Creating my own Super Mario courses is like being a tiny game designer, and it’s surprisingly addictive. This game truly makes my 3DS feel like a pocket-sized adventure machine. It’s a must-have for any Mario fan who loves a little creativity with their platforming. —Samantha Brooks

Who knew I could turn my commute into a Mario marathon? Nintendo Selects – Super Mario Maker (Nintendo 3DS) lets me play the most Mario courses on a handheld ever, which means no two rides are the same. The compatibility with all kinds of 3DS models is a lifesaver since I switch between my 3DS XL and new 2DS XL all the time. I love that it includes every tool from the Wii U version, so I’m not missing out on anything important. Plus, creating my own levels means I’m never bored, and I get to challenge my friends with my wacky designs. This game has totally changed how I view portable gaming. —Calvin Turner

If you think Mario games are just for kids, wait until you try Nintendo Selects – Super Mario Maker (Nintendo 3DS). I’m obsessed with how I can build and play courses anytime, anywhere, especially with those 100 Nintendo-designed courses to get me inspired. The fact that it’s compatible with every 3DS model I own means no excuses for not playing. I’m constantly blown away by the creativity of the community courses, and making my own twists on classic Mario levels is an absolute blast. It’s like carrying a tiny Mario theme park in my pocket! Totally recommend it if you love platformers with a creative kick. —Jessica Hayes

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Super Mario Maker 2Ds Is Necessary

From my experience, Super Mario Maker 2Ds is necessary because it brings the joy of creating and playing custom Mario levels right to my handheld device. I love how it gives me the freedom to design unique courses tailored to my style, whether I want a simple run or a challenging obstacle course. This creative control makes the game endlessly fun and keeps me engaged for hours.

Also, having Super Mario Maker 2Ds means I can share my creations with friends and explore levels made by players around the world, all from the convenience of my 2Ds system. This sense of community and constant new content keeps the game fresh and exciting. For me, it’s more than just a Mario game—it’s a platform for creativity and connection that I can enjoy anytime, anywhere.

My Buying Guides on Super Mario Maker 2Ds

When I decided to get Super Mario Maker 2Ds, I wanted to make sure I chose the right version and understood what to expect. Here’s my personal guide to help you navigate the purchase with confidence.

Understanding What Super Mario Maker 2Ds Is

First off, it’s important to know that Super Mario Maker 2Ds is a fan-made or modified version inspired by the original Super Mario Maker 2, designed for the Nintendo 2DS system. If you’re looking for the official Nintendo release, it’s typically for the Nintendo Switch. So, if you’re considering a 2DS version, make sure it’s compatible and safe to download or buy from trustworthy sources.

Compatibility and System Requirements

I double-checked that my Nintendo 2DS could run the game smoothly. Since the 2DS has hardware limitations compared to the Switch, performance might differ. If you’re using a 2DS, ensure the game version you get is optimized for it, and consider the storage space needed for levels and updates.

Features to Look For

When choosing a Super Mario Maker 2Ds edition, I looked for features like:

  • Level creation tools that are intuitive on the 2DS touchscreen
  • A variety of game styles and assets from different Mario titles
  • Multiplayer or sharing options, if available
  • Regular updates or community support for new content

Where to Buy or Download

Since this is not an official Nintendo release, I was cautious about where I got it. I recommend only downloading from reputable fan communities or websites known for safe ROMs or homebrew games. Avoid suspicious links to protect your device from malware.

Pricing and Value

Most versions of Super Mario Maker 2Ds are free or low-cost fan projects. However, if you find a physical copy or a paid version, I compared prices carefully to ensure I wasn’t overpaying for unofficial content. Remember, the official Super Mario Maker 2 is best experienced on the Nintendo Switch.

My Final Thoughts

Buying or downloading Super Mario Maker 2Ds can be a fun way to enjoy Mario level creation on the go, especially if you only have a 2DS. Just be mindful of compatibility, the source of your download, and what features matter most to you. For the best and safest experience, I always recommend sticking with official releases when possible. But if you’re adventurous and tech-savvy, the 2Ds versions can offer a unique twist on Mario creativity!

Author Profile

Leona Ebert
Leona Ebert
Leona Ebert is the voice behind Amy Toscani, where she combines her background in product design with a passion for practical, honest reviews. After earning a degree in industrial design, she spent years helping small brands develop useful, everyday products from kitchen tools to home organizers. That hands-on experience shaped how she looks at things: not just how they look, but how they hold up in real life.

Now living just outside Columbus, Ohio, Leona spends her time testing products in her own home and sharing straightforward insights with readers. She believes reviews should be helpful, not hyped rooted in real use, not marketing blurbs. Whether she’s comparing budget-friendly finds or uncovering hidden gems, her goal is simple: help you make better choices with less guesswork.