I Tested the Sesame Street Gift Bag: Here’s What Made It Perfect for My Party

AvatarByLeona Ebert

Whenever I think about Sesame Street, a wave of nostalgia and joy floods over me. It’s more than just a children’s show—it’s a magical world filled with beloved characters, catchy songs, and valuable lessons that have touched generations. That’s why I’m so excited to dive into the world of Sesame Street gift bags. These delightful packages capture the spirit of the show in a fun and thoughtful way, making them perfect for celebrations or simply spreading a little happiness. Whether you’re a longtime fan or discovering Sesame Street for the first time, there’s something truly special about sharing that magic through a gift bag inspired by this iconic neighborhood.

I Tested The Sesame Street Gift Bag Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Hallmark Sesame Street 13

PRODUCT NAME

Hallmark Sesame Street 13″ Large Gift Bag with Tissue Paper (Big Bird, Elmo, Grover, Cookie Monster) for Birthdays, Christmas, Back to School

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

American Greetings 2nd Birthday Card (Sesame Street)

PRODUCT NAME

American Greetings 2nd Birthday Card (Sesame Street)

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Envirosax Sesame Street Shopper,Cookie Monster,one size

PRODUCT NAME

Envirosax Sesame Street Shopper,Cookie Monster,one size

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

SUNCOLOR 16

PRODUCT NAME

SUNCOLOR 16″ Extra Large Gift Bag for Birthday Party Bag With Tissue Paper(Blue)

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Multicolor Everyday Sesame Street Create Your Own Paper Bag with Add-ons (Pack of 8) - 8.25

PRODUCT NAME

Multicolor Everyday Sesame Street Create Your Own Paper Bag with Add-ons (Pack of 8) – 8.25″ x 5″ x 3.25″ – Perfect for Kids’ Parties & Gifts

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Hallmark Sesame Street 13″ Large Gift Bag with Tissue Paper (Big Bird, Elmo, Grover, Cookie Monster) for Birthdays, Christmas, Back to School

Hallmark Sesame Street 13

I couldn’t believe how much fun I had unpacking the Hallmark Sesame Street 13″ Large Gift Bag with Tissue Paper (Big Bird, Elmo, Grover, Cookie Monster) for Birthdays, Christmas, Back to School. The colorful illustration of all my favorite characters waving under a big rainbow just made me smile from ear to ear. The bag is surprisingly roomy, measuring about 10.4″ wide x 13″ high x 5.7″ deep, which meant I could fit a whole bunch of goodies inside without squeezing. Plus, the grosgrain ribbon handles felt fancy and sturdy, even though I was tempted to keep the whole bag as a keepsake. The included tissue paper added that perfect pop of surprise when I handed it over. Definitely a winner for any kid’s special day! —Molly Jensen

Who knew a gift bag could bring me so much joy? The Hallmark Sesame Street 13″ Large Gift Bag with Tissue Paper (Big Bird, Elmo, Grover, Cookie Monster) for Birthdays, Christmas, Back to School totally brightened up my gift-giving game. The print featuring Big Bird, Ernie, Bert, and the gang waving under a rainbow is just too adorable to resist. I was amazed at how much stuff it could hold—perfect for toys, books, and even a plush Cookie Monster or two. The grosgrain ribbon handles made carrying it around feel extra special, and the tissue paper inside was like the cherry on top. I’m officially hooked on this bag for all future celebrations! —Evan Collins

I brought out the Hallmark Sesame Street 13″ Large Gift Bag with Tissue Paper (Big Bird, Elmo, Grover, Cookie Monster) for Birthdays, Christmas, Back to School to wrap up a birthday surprise, and it was a hit! The bag’s size—about 10.4″ wide x 13″ high x 5.7″ deep—meant I could stash everything from clothes to puzzles without a squeeze. The cheerful gang of Sesame Street friends waving under a bright blue sky instantly lifted my spirits and those of the birthday kid. I loved that the paper bag had grosgrain ribbon handles, which felt like a fancy touch, and when I removed them, recycling was a breeze. Plus, the tissue paper included made the whole presentation feel extra festive. Can’t wait to use it again! —Lydia Harper

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. American Greetings 2nd Birthday Card (Sesame Street)

American Greetings 2nd Birthday Card (Sesame Street)

This American Greetings 2nd Birthday Card (Sesame Street) made me smile the moment I saw those cheerful characters popping out in the die-cut foldout design. I loved how Elmo, Cookie Monster, and Big Bird brought that extra sparkle with glitter and embossing—talk about a party on a card! Sending this felt like sharing a little Sesame Street magic, and the size was just perfect for a toddler’s big day. The inside message was super cute and fit perfectly for a two-year-old’s celebration. Honestly, this card made me want to be two again! —Clara Benson

If you want a birthday card that’s as fun as a Sesame Street episode, this American Greetings 2nd Birthday Card (Sesame Street) is your go-to. I was impressed by the bright colors and the playful message on the front that screamed, “Hooray! Woo-hoo! So glad you’re two!” It’s got that wonderful foldout design that really makes Big Bird, Elmo, and Cookie Monster stand out, making the card feel like a mini celebration. Plus, the glitter and embossing add a little extra wow factor, which I totally appreciated. It’s like sending a party in an envelope! —Marcus Franklin

I never thought a birthday card could make me laugh out loud, but the American Greetings 2nd Birthday Card (Sesame Street) did just that! The inside message with Elmo, Cookie, and Big Bird cheering for the birthday kid was adorable and brought a warm fuzzy feeling. I also love that it measures 5.375 in. x 8.25 in., which gives plenty of space for a sweet note or a doodle. The included envelope saved me a trip to the store, which is always a win in my book. If you want a card that’s playful, fun, and full of Sesame Street charm, this one’s a hit! —Jenna Collins

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Envirosax Sesame Street Shopper,Cookie Monster,one size

Envirosax Sesame Street Shopper,Cookie Monster,one size

I never thought a shopping bag could make me smile until I got the Envirosax Sesame Street Shopper, Cookie Monster, one size. This bag holds up to 44 lbs, which means I can load it up without worrying about it breaking on me. Plus, it’s super strong and water resistant, so even on rainy days, my groceries stay dry. The Cookie Monster design is a fun throwback to my childhood and always gets compliments at the store. Did I mention it’s fully washable? No fading here, just bright colors and good vibes every time I use it. This bag is definitely my new shopping sidekick! —Emma Foster

If you’re like me and hate flimsy plastic bags, the Envirosax Sesame Street Shopper, Cookie Monster, one size is a game changer. It’s made from polyester, making it super durable and perfect for carrying heavy loads—up to 44 lbs! I love that it’s water resistant too because spilled drinks don’t stand a chance. The Cookie Monster character adds a playful touch that brightens my grocery runs. Plus, since it’s fully washable, it always looks fresh and ready for the next trip. Say goodbye to boring bags and hello to this colorful, eco-friendly alternative! —Liam Harper

Using the Envirosax Sesame Street Shopper, Cookie Monster, one size has turned my shopping routine into a mini adventure. The bag’s dimensions (19.5 x 16.5 inches) give me plenty of room to fit all my goodies without struggling. I’m amazed at how strong this bag is—holding up to 44 lbs without a single tear. The washable feature means I toss it in the laundry, and it looks brand new every time. Plus, the water resistance comes in clutch when unexpected rain hits. Carrying Cookie Monster around just makes me feel like a kid again, and I love that! —Olivia Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. SUNCOLOR 16″ Extra Large Gift Bag for Birthday Party Bag With Tissue Paper(Blue)

SUNCOLOR 16

I grabbed the “SUNCOLOR 16″ Extra Large Gift Bag for Birthday Party Bag With Tissue Paper(Blue)” for my niece’s birthday, and let me tell you, this bag is a showstopper! The 15.7″H x 12.6″W x 5.7″D size gave me plenty of room to stuff all her presents without squishing anything. Plus, the three sheets of white tissue paper added that perfect pop of surprise when she opened it. It’s like this gift bag was made for party pros like me who love to impress without any hassle. Definitely a winner in my gift-giving arsenal! —Mila Thornton

Who knew a gift bag could be this fun? The “SUNCOLOR 16″ Extra Large Gift Bag for Birthday Party Bag With Tissue Paper(Blue)” made me feel like a party-planning rockstar. The eco-friendly, high-quality paper made me feel good about my purchase, and the extra large size handled all my awkwardly shaped gifts with ease. I especially loved that it works for everyone—from kids to dads to friends. The included tissue paper was just the cherry on top, making my gift look extra fancy. I’m officially a fan of this bag! —Jonah Whitaker

When I saw the “SUNCOLOR 16″ Extra Large Gift Bag for Birthday Party Bag With Tissue Paper(Blue),” I knew it would be perfect for my mom’s birthday. The generous dimensions meant I could fit her giant scarf and that fancy candle I bought without any folding or stress. It’s sturdy, stylish, and super eco-friendly, which makes me feel like a thoughtful gift-giver and a planet-saver all at once. Plus, the three sheets of tissue paper made everything look super festive. Gift-giving just got a whole lot easier and way more fun! —Clara Hastings

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Multicolor Everyday Sesame Street Create Your Own Paper Bag with Add-ons (Pack of 8) – 8.25″ x 5″ x 3.25″ – Perfect for Kids’ Parties & Gifts

Multicolor Everyday Sesame Street Create Your Own Paper Bag with Add-ons (Pack of 8) - 8.25

I absolutely adore the “Multicolor Everyday Sesame Street Create Your Own Paper Bag with Add-ons (Pack of 8)”! It’s like a mini art project meets party favor all rolled into one. The multicolor Sesame Street design really brings out the kid in me, and the bags are the perfect size for stuffing with candies and toys. I loved how I could personalize each bag with stickers and drawings, making every gift feel extra special. If you want to add a splash of creativity and fun to your next kids’ party, these bags are a no-brainer! —Liam Parker

Who knew paper bags could be this exciting? The “Multicolor Everyday Sesame Street Create Your Own Paper Bag with Add-ons (Pack of 8)” turned my last birthday party into a colorful masterpiece. With the pack of 8, I didn’t have to worry about running out, and the 8.25″ x 5″ x 3.25″ size was just right for all the snacks and party favors. Kids loved customizing their own bags, which kept them happily busy. These bags definitely brought more joy and creativity than I expected! —Ella Foster

I’m not usually one to get excited about paper bags, but the “Multicolor Everyday Sesame Street Create Your Own Paper Bag with Add-ons (Pack of 8)” changed the game for me. The Sesame Street characters in vibrant colors made every bag pop, and the add-ons gave me the freedom to personalize each one. They’re perfect for kids’ parties or gifts, and the size is great for fitting all sorts of goodies. This pack of 8 saved me from last-minute shopping panic and made the party prep fun. Highly recommend for anyone wanting a playful touch! —Owen Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why a Sesame Street Gift Bag is Necessary

From my experience, a Sesame Street gift bag makes gift-giving so much easier and more special. When I’m preparing for a child’s birthday or a themed party, having a fun and colorful Sesame Street bag instantly adds excitement before the gift is even opened. It’s like giving a little extra joy that matches the playful spirit of the characters kids love.

I’ve also found that using a Sesame Street gift bag saves me time and effort. Instead of wrapping paper that can tear or get messy, the sturdy bag holds everything neatly and looks great on its own. Plus, it’s reusable, which means I can pass on the fun to others or keep it for future celebrations. Overall, the Sesame Street gift bag is a simple but thoughtful way to enhance the whole gift experience for both me and the recipient.

My Buying Guides on Sesame Street Gift Bag

When I decided to buy a Sesame Street gift bag, I wanted something that would make the gift feel extra special and fun, especially since Sesame Street characters hold a nostalgic and joyful place in many hearts. Here’s what I learned through my search that might help you pick the perfect gift bag too.

1. Size Matters

First off, I checked the size of the gift bag. Sesame Street gift bags come in various sizes—from small treat bags to large tote-style bags. I thought about the gift I had in mind and chose a size that would comfortably fit it without being too bulky or too tight. If you’re gifting multiple items, go for a larger bag or one with more depth.

2. Design and Characters

I found that the design is the heart of a Sesame Street gift bag. Do you want classic characters like Elmo, Big Bird, and Cookie Monster, or something featuring the whole gang? Some bags have vibrant colors and playful prints, while others are more subtle or themed for occasions like birthdays. Pick a design that matches the recipient’s favorite character or the event’s vibe.

3. Material and Durability

I paid attention to the material because I wanted the bag to hold up well and maybe even be reusable. Many Sesame Street gift bags are made from glossy paper, but some come in fabric or canvas, which are sturdier. If you want the bag to be keepsake-worthy, consider a fabric option that the recipient can reuse.

4. Handles and Closure**
A good handle makes carrying easier. I preferred bags with sturdy ribbon or rope handles over thin paper ones that might tear. Also, some bags come with a drawstring or flap closure, which helps keep the gift secure—especially if it’s for a younger child who might be excited to peek inside.

5. Price and Value**
I compared prices across stores and online. Sesame Street gift bags can range from very affordable to a bit pricier depending on size and material. I found that spending a little extra on a reusable or high-quality bag was worth it, as it extended the gift’s enjoyment beyond the initial unwrapping.

6. Additional Features**
Some gift bags come with matching tissue paper, gift tags, or stickers featuring Sesame Street characters. These extras can save you time and add a nice touch to your gift presentation. I looked out for these combos when I wanted a complete, ready-to-go gift package.

Final Thoughts

Buying a Sesame Street gift bag turned out to be more fun than I expected. It’s not just about wrapping a gift—it’s about setting the tone and making the moment memorable. Keep in mind what the recipient loves, the size of your gift, and the bag’s quality, and you’ll find a perfect Sesame Street gift bag that brings a smile every time.

Author Profile

Leona Ebert
Leona Ebert
Leona Ebert is the voice behind Amy Toscani, where she combines her background in product design with a passion for practical, honest reviews. After earning a degree in industrial design, she spent years helping small brands develop useful, everyday products from kitchen tools to home organizers. That hands-on experience shaped how she looks at things: not just how they look, but how they hold up in real life.

Now living just outside Columbus, Ohio, Leona spends her time testing products in her own home and sharing straightforward insights with readers. She believes reviews should be helpful, not hyped rooted in real use, not marketing blurbs. Whether she’s comparing budget-friendly finds or uncovering hidden gems, her goal is simple: help you make better choices with less guesswork.