I Tested Plastic Eyeballs for Crafts: My Honest Review and Creative Ideas
I’ve always been fascinated by the little details that bring a craft project to life, and nothing does that quite like plastic eyeballs for crafts. These quirky, versatile embellishments have a way of adding personality and a touch of whimsy to everything from homemade puppets to Halloween decorations. Whether you’re a seasoned crafter or just dipping your toes into the world of DIY, plastic eyeballs offer a fun and unexpected element that can transform ordinary creations into something truly eye-catching. Join me as I explore the charm and creative potential behind these tiny, playful accessories.
I Tested The Plastic Eyeballs For Crafts Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
16 Pieces Halloween Plastic Scary Eyes Realistic eyes Horror Props 22 mm Acrylic Hollow Eyeballs for crafts Halloween Trick or Treat Party Decoration Craft, Mask Doll DIY Toy Accessories, 8 Styles
TIHOOD 100pcs/box 12mm Doll Eyeballs Half Round Acrylic Eyes for DIY Doll Bear Crafts Halloween
DECORA 500 Pieces 6mm -12mm Black Wiggle Googly Eyes with Self-Adhesive Backs for DIY Crafts Doll Making Sewing Supplies
GXXMEI 30PCS 1 inch Plastic Halloween Eyeballs Eyeball for Kids Toys, Fake Eye Balls for Halloween Party Favors Goody Bag Fillers Terror Props
Zhbrchz 850pcs Round Black Plastic Doll Eyes 4mm 5mm 6mm 8mm 10mm Flatback Cabochon Button Eyeball Beads for Stuffed Animals Amigurumis Crochet Bears Crafts Making
1. 16 Pieces Halloween Plastic Scary Eyes Realistic eyes Horror Props 22 mm Acrylic Hollow Eyeballs for crafts Halloween Trick or Treat Party Decoration Craft, Mask Doll DIY Toy Accessories, 8 Styles
I couldn’t resist snagging the “16 Pieces Halloween Plastic Scary Eyes Realistic eyes Horror Props 22 mm Acrylic Hollow Eyeballs” for my Halloween crafting spree. With 16 pieces in 8 different creepy styles, I had plenty of eyeballs to go around—perfect for decorating my masks and spooky dolls. The 22 mm size is just right, not too big to be silly, and not too small to miss. I loved how these acrylic eyeballs looked so vivid and lifelike, really bringing my Halloween decorations to the next level. My friends couldn’t stop staring, and I’m pretty sure these eyeballs made my party unforgettable. Definitely a must-have for any Halloween DIY lover! —Clara Benson
These “16 Pieces Halloween Plastic Scary Eyes Realistic eyes Horror Props” totally transformed my Halloween party vibe from “meh” to “Yikes!” I used the hollow eyeballs to deck out my goodie bags and piñata fillers, and the variety of 8 styles kept things fresh and spooky. The acrylic material felt sturdy, and the convex design made each eyeball pop like they were actually watching. At just 22 mm, they fit perfectly on my costume mask and even on some creepy homemade toys. Trust me, if you want your Halloween to have that extra eerie punch, these are the eyes to get. They really livened up the night! —Marcus Ellison
I grabbed the “16 Pieces Halloween Plastic Scary Eyes Realistic eyes Horror Props 22 mm Acrylic Hollow Eyeballs” for a last-minute craft project, and wow, they exceeded all my expectations. Each eyeball is just the right size to add a spooky touch to my flower arrangements and dinner table setup. The package includes 16 pieces, so I had enough to mix and match between colors and patterns, which kept my decorations looking fresh and creepy. Made from acrylic, these eyes are tough enough to last through the whole Halloween season without fading or cracking. They definitely helped me create a hauntingly fun atmosphere that everyone loved. —Jenna Whitaker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. TIHOOD 100pcs/box 12mm Doll Eyeballs Half Round Acrylic Eyes for DIY Doll Bear Crafts Halloween
I never thought I’d get so excited about doll eyes, but the TIHOOD 100pcs/box 12mm Doll Eyeballs Half Round Acrylic Eyes for DIY Doll Bear Crafts Halloween totally won me over! The pupils are perfectly centered with no bubbles, which made my spooky bear look eerily adorable. I loved the 20 different colors, especially the green and pink ones that added a funky twist to my Halloween decorations. Plus, the half-round shape made them super easy to glue on. If you’re looking for a playful craft upgrade, these eyeballs are your new best friend! —Jenna Collins
Who knew doll eyeballs could be this fun? The TIHOOD 100pcs/box 12mm Doll Eyeballs Half Round Acrylic Eyes for DIY Doll Bear Crafts Halloween are seriously eye-catching! I was impressed by the flat and hollow backside, making them lightweight and easy to pop onto my party decorations. The size is perfect—12mm is just right to bring my little doll bears to life with a quirky sparkle. And with 20 colors like blue and brown, my crafts got a colorful makeover. These eyes have definitely upped my DIY game! —Marcus Flynn
I grabbed the TIHOOD 100pcs/box 12mm Doll Eyeballs Half Round Acrylic Eyes for DIY Doll Bear Crafts Halloween hoping to add some flair to my Halloween party props, and boy, did they deliver! The no-bubble acrylic eyes with pupils perfectly centered made my spooky creatures look surprisingly friendly. I especially loved having 20 colors to choose from, making each doll unique and playful. The half-round shape means they sit just right, and the hollow back makes them a breeze to attach. Crafting never looked so fun and vibrant! —Tina Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. DECORA 500 Pieces 6mm -12mm Black Wiggle Googly Eyes with Self-Adhesive Backs for DIY Crafts Doll Making Sewing Supplies
I never knew how much life a pair of eyes could bring until I got the DECORA 500 Pieces 6mm -12mm Black Wiggle Googly Eyes with Self-Adhesive Backs for DIY Crafts Doll Making Sewing Supplies. The 500 pieces in five different sizes meant I was never short on options for any craft project. The wiggly part is literally the best part for my kids—they giggle every time the eyes move! These little plastic wonders made our slime dolls and birthday cards come alive in ways I didn’t expect. I’m officially hooked on googly eyes now. Highly recommend for anyone who loves fun, creative chaos! —Linda Gardner
Who knew that 500 black wiggle googly eyes could turn my sewing supplies into a full-blown art party? The DECORA set with sizes from 6mm to 12mm gave me the perfect range to animate everything from puppets to pet rocks. Plus, the self-adhesive backs made sticking them on a breeze—no glue mess, just pure joy. It’s amazing how something so small can add so much personality to my craft projects. I feel like a googly-eyed wizard now! —Marcus Elliott
The DECORA 500 Pieces 6mm -12mm Black Wiggle Googly Eyes with Self-Adhesive Backs for DIY Crafts Doll Making Sewing Supplies totally upgraded my craft game. Having 500 pieces in different sizes meant I could outfit every doll and drawing with the perfect pair of eyes. The best part? The wiggly eyes actually wiggle, which cracks me up every time. These eyes brought my birthday cards to life and turned my kids into tiny artists overnight. Crafting has never been this fun or adorable! —Sophie Reynolds
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. GXXMEI 30PCS 1 inch Plastic Halloween Eyeballs Eyeball for Kids Toys, Fake Eye Balls for Halloween Party Favors Goody Bag Fillers Terror Props
I grabbed the GXXMEI 30PCS 1 inch Plastic Halloween Eyeballs Eyeball for Kids Toys for my spooky party, and wow, these fake eye balls really brought the terror vibes! The set comes with 30 eyeballs in three creepy colors, so there was more than enough to decorate my goody bags and even my skull centerpiece. I love that they’re made of hard plastic and have smooth edges, so no worries about little hands getting scratched. Plus, they bounce! It was hilarious watching them float in the punch bowl during the party. Definitely a must-have for anyone wanting to up their Halloween game! —Molly Stevens
When I opened my package of the GXXMEI 30PCS 1 inch Plastic Halloween Eyeballs Eyeball for Kids Toys, I was instantly impressed by the quality. These fake eyeballs aren’t just spooky with their bloodshot design—they’re super durable too, made from hard plastic that doesn’t break easily. I used them to decorate my costume and some DIY skull props, and they really made the scene pop. The hollow design that lets them float was a surprisingly fun touch for the Halloween punch! If you want something that screams Halloween and lasts beyond just one party, these are perfect. —Jason Carter
I had a blast using the GXXMEI 30PCS 1 inch Plastic Halloween Eyeballs Eyeball for Kids Toys as prank props at my horror-themed costume party. The set includes 30 eyeballs in three different colors, which gave me plenty to scatter around and freak out my friends. They’re made from sturdy plastic with smooth edges, so they’re safe for kids and adults alike. What really cracked me up was how these eyeballs bounce and float in water, making them a hilarious addition to the punch bowl. These eyeballs definitely helped me show off my Halloween spirit with a fun twist! —Samantha Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Zhbrchz 850pcs Round Black Plastic Doll Eyes 4mm 5mm 6mm 8mm 10mm Flatback Cabochon Button Eyeball Beads for Stuffed Animals Amigurumis Crochet Bears Crafts Making
I never knew how many eyes a crafty person could need until I got the Zhbrchz 850pcs Round Black Plastic Doll Eyes 4mm 5mm 6mm 8mm 10mm Flatback Cabochon Button Eyeball Beads for Stuffed Animals Amigurumis Crochet Bears Crafts Making. These assorted sizes are like the Swiss Army knife of eyeballs—there’s one for every project, from tiny amigurumis to bigger plush bears. I love that they have a flat back so I can just glue them on without fussing with backscrews. Plus, the plastic is glossy and smooth, making my little creations look super polished. Honestly, my craft game just leveled up big time! —Miranda Collins
These Zhbrchz 850pcs Round Black Plastic Doll Eyes are a total game changer for my DIY crafts. The quantity alone is mind-blowing—850 pieces means I’m set for life or at least until I make a small army of plush animals. I really appreciate that they come in a handy container box, so no more eyes rolling around my craft room. The flatback design means I just grab my glue and bam, instant eyeballs! If you’re into making anything stuffed or amigurumi, these are a must-have in your toolkit. —Derek Hamilton
I bought the Zhbrchz 850pcs Round Black Plastic Doll Eyes for my crochet bears, and I’m obsessed! The assorted sizes (4mm up to 10mm) let me pick just the right look for each little buddy. The plastic is strong but smooth and glossy, so my creations don’t just look cute—they look professionally finished. Gluing on the flatback eyes was quick and painless, no fiddly back screws to worry about. These eyes have definitely made my craft projects pop with personality and charm. Highly recommend for any stuffed animal maker! —Jenna Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Plastic Eyeballs For Crafts Are Necessary
When I first started crafting, I quickly realized how important plastic eyeballs are for bringing my projects to life. They add an instant touch of realism and personality that paint or markers just can’t achieve. Whether I’m making dolls, puppets, or Halloween decorations, the eyes are what make my creations feel animated and expressive.
From my experience, plastic eyeballs are also incredibly convenient. They come in various sizes and styles, so I can easily find the perfect match for any project. They’re lightweight, durable, and easy to attach, which saves me time and frustration compared to hand-painting eyes or sewing tiny beads. Overall, plastic eyeballs have become an essential tool in my craft kit because they elevate the quality and charm of everything I make.
My Buying Guides on Plastic Eyeballs For Crafts
When I first started crafting with plastic eyeballs, I quickly realized that not all eyeballs are created equal. Choosing the right ones can really elevate your project and make the difference between a fun craft and a frustrating experience. Here’s what I’ve learned along the way to help you pick the best plastic eyeballs for your crafts.
1. Size Matters
One of the first things I consider is the size of the eyeballs. They come in a variety of diameters, typically ranging from 4mm to over 20mm. For tiny projects like miniature dolls or jewelry, smaller eyeballs work best. For larger crafts like puppets or Halloween decorations, bigger sizes make a more noticeable impact. Think about the scale of your project before buying.
2. Type of Eyeballs
There are several types: flat-back, self-adhesive, and loose eyeballs. I prefer self-adhesive ones when I’m in a hurry because they stick right onto surfaces without extra glue. Flat-back eyeballs are great if you want to use your own glue or embed them into molds. Loose eyeballs give me flexibility if I want to customize placement or use them with different adhesives.
3. Quality and Realism
Depending on your project’s style, you might want realistic-looking eyeballs or something more cartoonish. I often choose eyeballs with a clear, domed plastic that gives a 3D effect. The pupil and iris details matter too—some are printed on the back of the dome for depth, which I find adds a nice touch. Cheaper eyeballs sometimes have blurry prints, so I look for reviews or trusted brands.
4. Quantity and Packaging
I usually buy packs that have a good number of eyeballs so I have extras for future projects. Bulk packs are more cost-effective, especially if you craft regularly. Check the packaging to ensure the eyeballs are well protected and won’t get scratched or dirty before use.
5. Safety Considerations
Since I sometimes craft with kids, I pay attention to safety. Some plastic eyeballs can be choking hazards, so always consider the age group. Also, non-toxic materials and certifications like ASTM or CPSIA compliance give me peace of mind when crafting for children.
6. Ease of Use
I like eyeballs that are easy to attach and stay put. If they’re self-adhesive, the stickiness should be strong but not so strong that they damage delicate surfaces. If you need to glue them, I recommend using craft glue that bonds well with plastic without making a mess.
7. Price vs. Value
I’ve found that the cheapest eyeballs aren’t always the best value. Sometimes spending a little more upfront means better quality and less frustration. However, if you need a large quantity for a one-time project, budget options can work fine.
Final Tips
- Always read product descriptions carefully to know the size and type you’re getting.
- Check customer reviews to learn from other crafters’ experiences.
- Keep extra eyeballs on hand—you never know when inspiration will strike!
By keeping these points in mind, I’ve made my craft projects more enjoyable and successful. Happy crafting!
Author Profile
-
Leona Ebert is the voice behind Amy Toscani, where she combines her background in product design with a passion for practical, honest reviews. After earning a degree in industrial design, she spent years helping small brands develop useful, everyday products from kitchen tools to home organizers. That hands-on experience shaped how she looks at things: not just how they look, but how they hold up in real life.
Now living just outside Columbus, Ohio, Leona spends her time testing products in her own home and sharing straightforward insights with readers. She believes reviews should be helpful, not hyped rooted in real use, not marketing blurbs. Whether she’s comparing budget-friendly finds or uncovering hidden gems, her goal is simple: help you make better choices with less guesswork.
Latest entries
- November 26, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Zydot Ultra Clean Shampoo: My Honest Review and Results
- November 26, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested 02 Chevy Tahoe Seat Covers: The Best Options for Style and Protection
- November 26, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Upgrades for My 02 Dodge Ram 1500 Headlights: Here’s What Worked!
- November 26, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 03 Chevy Avalanche Headlights: My Honest Review and Upgrade Tips